The following tabulation summarizes the minor discrepancies found among the various sources:

 

Grimes, Lucinda A.

[1] and [2], same info

Grimes, Mary J.

“Mary J.” [2] (Mary Jane Grimes) [33]; vs. “Mary L.” [1] [3]

Hadley, infant daughter

“infant” [1], “infant daughter” “born and died” [2]

Harlan, Oliver

[1] and [2], same info; “Oliver” [4b] (Louise McAninch 1963)

Harlan, Polly S.

“wife of Jno. S. Harlan” [1] [2]; “Jonathan S. Harlan” [3a1]

 

“Polly S.” (Louise McAninch, 1963) [4b, letter]

King, Anna M.

[1], [2], [3a2 (Accas note, 1977)], same info; [5] [5g] [5h]

King, John

[1], [2], [3a1], same info

King, Rebecca

[1], [2], same info; erroneous “wife of John King” [3a1] [3b]

McAninch, Charles W.

[1], [2], [3b], same info; [3b] corrected “J. & E. J.”; 1963 [4b]

McAninch, Clara

“dau. of E. G. & A. McAninch” [4b] (Louise McA., 1963);

 

“dau. of E. G. & C. A.” [1] [3]; vs. “E. G. & J. A.” [2]

McAninch, Hiram D.

[1] and [2], same info; “Hiram D.” [4b] (Louise McA., 1963)

McAninch, Isabelle

[1] [2] correct; erroneous “wife of John McAninch” [3a1] [3b];

 

“Isabelle” (Louise McAninch, 1963) [4b, letter]

McAninch, Phebe E.

[1], [2], [3b], same info

McAninch, Samuel

“Samuel” [1] [2] [4a4] [4a5] [4b] (Louise McAninch, 1963);

 

incorrect date of birth [1] [2] [see Note 12] [12d] [12e] [12f];

 

incorrect name Ernest / Earnest [3] [see section III. C., below]

McAninch, Sarah C.

[1] and [2], same info

Phillips, infant daughter

[2] only [see ‘Phillips family’ section, below]

Phillips, Sally

“Sally” [1], “Sally Sides” [2]

Phillips, Samuel E.

“Samuel E.” [1], Samuel “(E)” [2], “Samuel Elwood” [3]

[Phillips, Susan]

[2] only [possibly an erroneous entry, see ‘Harlan family’]

Pike, Margaret A.

“dau. of T. & P. Pike” [1] [2]; vs. [3] “T.U.P. Pike”

Pike, Nancy Catherine

[1], [2], [3], same info

 

Another section of this report,

“Analysis and Identification of Family Groups, from Pleasant Hill Cemetery Records”,

contains additional information on the families associated with the Pleasant Hill community 

(Grimes, Hadley, Hancock, Harlan, King, Mann, McAninch, Phillips, Pike, Ridpath, and Tincher)

 

There are two additional Phillips names that appear on only one list, Mrs. Ennis Johnson’s letter [2]:

[2] 20. “Susan Phillips, wife of Enoch Harlan” [Susan (Phillips) Harlan, wife of Enoch Harlan]

[2] 21. “Infant daughter of Jonathan F. Phillips and Makina Couch Phillips, sister to Olney Phillips”

These two additional people are discussed further in the ‘Harlan family’ and ‘Phillips family’ sections of this report, respectively.

 

 

“Old Pleasant Hill Methodist Cemetery”, Copyright 2003, by Frank McAninch       page 11 of 68

Permission granted to copy freely for any non-commercial purpose except copyrights owned by others

 

Table of Contents for this Article

Top of this Page

Previous Page

Next Page