[22] |
Re The Men, Women, Events, Institutions & Lore of Casey County, Kentucky book |
|
by W. M. Watkins, pub. 1939, Standard Printing Company, Louisville, Kentucky; |
|
"‘McAninch Tree’ in the 1939 Casey County, Kentucky, book", MFHN v.XV n.3 |
|
July 2007 p.2007-21 http://www.mcaninch.net/Newsletter/mfn15y07/m15p21w6.htm |
|
|
[23] |
Expanded 1810 (pg.19) and [15] (pg.24), added new [24], Nov. 2021, Frank McAninch |
|
|
[24] |
"Isabella Doane" in Yates Publication's 1980s Family Group Sheet Exchange, charts |
|
given to them with no source documentation (Yates http://www.yates.montana.com). |
|
It shows 'Samuel Mcaninch b.1789 PA' and 'Spouse Isabella Doane of KY, mar. 1809', |
|
copied as "Yates Publishing. U.S. and International Marriage Records, 1560-1900" by |
|
ancestry.com in 2004, database from "pedigree charts, family history articles, queries". |
|
In the 1990s, based on the Yates publications, included her in the newsletter (with '?'s) |
|
"2 - Samuel McAninch (b.1789 [ |
|
sp1?- (Isabella? Doane?) (b.?, d.1810) [d.1809-1810?, not confirmed, ’99/fm] |
|
3 - Sally McAninch (b.1810, KY?) [Samantha may be only child?, ’99/fm] |
|
sp- George Hancock, 1 child ( |
|
March 1993 p.1993-02 www.mcaninch.net/Newsletter/mfn01y93/m01p02w6.htm |
|
Trust, but verify; many attempts to trace and verify the Isabel(la) Doan(e) story, never |
|
found any real document(s) (not bible, census, county, church, deeds, nor state records). |
|
Samuel probably did have a first wife, mother of Sarah 'Sally', and she may have been |
|
Isabel(la) Doan(e). However, the Yates FGS / ancestry.com stories are undocumented |
|
derivative secondary data, with no sources, and it is difficult to trust unconfirmed data. |
|
|
Ref.: |
Partially inspired by the many errors that have been uploaded to ancestry.com online |
|
databases, all with multiple mistakes and errors, errors which cannot be corrected: |
|
[one says] Daniel McAninch was born in 1751 in Antrim, Antrim, Northern Ireland. |
|
He married Mary Smith and they had one son together. He also had four sons from |
|
another relationship. He died in 1822 in Tennessee at the age of 71. . . . |
|
Daniel McAninch married Mary Smith in Franklin, Kentucky, on June 11, 1775, . . . |
|
Daniel McAninch lived in Westmoreland City, Pennsylvania, in 1790. . . . |
|
His son George A was born in 1795 in Westmoreland City, Pennsylvania. . . . |
|
person.ancestrylibrary.com/tree/11603243/person/182757427/story |
|
[another says] When Henry McAninch was born in 1802, his father, Daniel, was 51. |
|
He had four brothers. His son John Henry was born in 1825 in Tennessee. . . . |
|
Henry McAninch lived in Giles, Tennessee, in 1836. . . . |
|
person.ancestrylibrary.com/tree/11603243/person/832354723/story |
|
[and a third says] Isabella Doane was born in 1792 in Kentucky. She married Samuel |
|
McAninch in 1809 in Pennsylvania. She died as a teenager in 1810 in Pennsylvania. |
|
Her daughter Samatha [sic, spelling] Sallie was born in 1810 in Pennsylvania . . . |
|
person.ancestrylibrary.com/tree/11603243/person/844562054/story |
|
|
Note |
These errors in the online databases appear to confuse the two Daniel McAninch’s |
|
(father and son), and confusion with the children of the younger Daniel McAninch, |
|
who married Dorcas Burks, and they had four sons [see “Burks” “Myth”, p.18] [10] |
|
______________________________________________________________________ |
|
Daniel McAninch and Families in Kentucky: Myths, Fables, Facts and Fiction [23] |
|
McAninch Family History NL v.XXIX n.2 / Copyright Frank McAninch / pg.2021-26 |
|
|
|
Table of Contents for this Year First Page of this Issue Previous Page Next Page |