Birth |
Family stories may say "born 1765, Greene, Tennessee", or "born in Greene County, |
Myths |
Tennessee, in 1771", and/or "born in the early 1770's in Kentucky", although analysis |
|
of the historical records shows that those statements cannot be accurate. |
|
1. William was born before 1765, long before Kentucky or Tennessee became states: |
|
a. Kentucky became our 15th state in 1792 (originally, western territory of Virginia); |
|
b. Greene County, North Carolina ("Greene", not "Green"), was originally created |
|
on 17 May 1783, set off from Washington County, North Carolina; |
|
c. Tennessee became our 16th state in 1796, at which time Greene County became |
|
Greene County, Tennessee (Tennessee was originally the western territory of N.C.). |
|
2. William was married 7 Oct. 1796, in Greene County, eastern Tennessee, shortly |
|
before migrating through the Cumberland Gap from Tennessee into Kentucky [5]. |
|
|
|
Only two of William’s children (his two youngest sons, Samuel and Jesse) lived long |
|
enough to be enumerated in the 1880 census, which was the first census that asked each |
|
person where his or her parents had been born. And, in the 1880 census, 67 years after |
|
William's death in 1813, both of his two youngest sons, Samuel, age 74 [20] (1880), |
|
and Jesse, age 69 [24] (1880), said 'father born Kentucky' and 'mother born Kentucky'. |
|
Samuel and Jesse were both born in Kentucky, and knew their parents 'from Kentucky'; |
|
however, we can be sure that William 'born before 1765' was NOT born in Kentucky. |
|
The land area of present-day Kentucky was Virginia territory before 1792, and, if |
|
William (born before 1765),had actually been born in the Virginia area of present-day |
|
Kentucky, then William would be named in all of the history books as one of the first |
|
white children born in the ‘over mountain’ Indian country west of the Appalachians. |
|
|
|
So, could William have been born in 1771, or born sometime early in the 1770s? |
|
Possibly, if the 1810 census was wrong (we do not know who gave the information). |
|
However, was he born in the Indian country (Kentucky or Tennessee)? Certainly not. |
|
|
1780s |
There were multiple pioneer McA/Ninch’s in early western Pennsylvania [1] [2]. |
and |
Two of these, Daniel McAninch (b.1748-1750) and William McAninch (b.bef.1765), |
1790s |
were probably related (brothers?, cousins? unknown), and traveled together down the |
|
Great Valley of the Shenandoah River and through the Cumberland Gap into Kentucky. |
|
|
1780s |
William’s oldest son, James McAninch, was born before 1786 |
|
(where was William McAninch in the 1780s? Pennsylvania? Virginia? Tennessee?) |
|
1. James is '1 white male over 21' on the 1808 land entry (implies born before 1786) |
|
(15 Apr. 1808, 153 acres, Fishing Creek, white male over 21, 1 horse). [10] (James) |
|
2. James 'born before 1784' per 1810 census ("1 male, 26-45") [22], |
|
3. and James is an adult witness with expenses paid in an 1810 court case [23]. |
|
|
Myths |
James was not "born 1797 Kentucky" (if born 1797, he would be only 10 or 11 in 1808, |
|
vs. ‘over 21’ on the 1808 tax record, and he would be only 12 or 13 in the 1810 records). |
|
|
|
______________________________________________________________________ |
|
William McAninch (born before 1765; died 1813, Casey County, Kentucky) |
|
McA. Family. Hist. NL v.XXIX n.1 May 2021 Copyright Frank McAninch p2021-04 |
|
|
|
Table of Contents for this Year First Page of this Issue Previous Page Next Page |