m06p13w6

[16] Joseph McAninch, Coatesville, Probationers, 1862, Single, Pleasant Hill Class [H.2., est. 1863],

Coatesville? Class [H.5., prob. (18)73], Member, 1879, Coatesville Class 1881, Coatesville Class

1882 (“Dismissed by letter, Aug. 1883”). This is Joseph F. McAninch, born 1845, son of Daniel

and Phebe (Pike) McAninch, who married Amy E. (Elizabeth) Howerton, 19 Nov. 1868 [Note 7].

[and, could not be Joseph McA., born 1821, Kentucky, son of Samuel and Polly McA., married

Elizabeth Jane Quiett, 1845, near Paris, Edgar County, Illinois, for two reasons – 1) he was not

“Single” in 1862, and 2) although they lived in Amo until 1866, they moved to Iowa in that year].

[17] Lily A. McAninch, Amo, Baptism 1867. Believed to be Lydia A. McAninch, born 3 April 1867,

daughter of Enoch G. (George) and Araunah (Knighten) McAninch [see Notes 4, 5, 13, 19].

[18] Mary McAninch, Coatesville, Member 1867, Coatesville? Class [H.5., prob. (18)73], Member,

1879, Coatesville Class 1881. Who is this Mary McAninch ?

[19] Mary Elizabeth McAninch, Hendricks County, Baptism 1863. Could be daughter of Enoch G.

and Araunah (Knighten) McAninch, born 5 May 1863, in Hendricks Co., baptized before they

moved to Iowa? (their Mary E. died 1866, buried Shaha Cem., Ringgold Co., Iowa); or, Mary E.

(Elizabeth?) McA., b.ca.1862, daughter of John W. and Martha Ann (Smith) McA. [Notes 14, 21]

[20] Mary [Johnson] McAninch, Coatesville, Member 1861, then “Removed by letter”; wife of

William S. McAninch, married 1 Feb. 1859; went to Iowa after the Civil War [see Notes 10, 30].

[21] Martha A. McAninch, Pleasant Hill, Member 1861, Member 1862, Pleasant Hill Class [H.2.,

est. 1863], Amo, Member 1867, “Not member since 1873”. Wife of John W. McA. [Note 14].

[22] Martha M. McAninch, Coatesville, Baptism 1873 [DOB not given, could be an adult baptism?];

Coatesville, Probationers, 1873 [could be new member]; and M. M. McAninch, Coatesville?

Class [H.5., prob. (18)73]. Who is this Martha M. McAninch ? [not Martha A. McA. (Note 21),

and not Mary M. (Johnson) McA., wife of Wm. S. McA., they went to Iowa after Civil War].

[23] Maude McAninch, Member, circa 1906-1916, “Removed without letter”. Born 1890, daughter

of Daniel A. and Rhoda (Wilson) McA.; Maude married Loren Bilderbeck, and went to Florida.

[24] Nancy McAninch, Coatesville Class, 1881. Who is this? Nancy Jane (Allee) McA.? [Note 15].

[25] Permelia C. [Catherine] McAninch, born 1826, daughter of Samuel and Polly McA.;

Coatesville, Member 1861, 1862, Coatesville Class [H.1., est. 1862], Member 1867, Coatesville

Class 1870, Coatesville Class [H.4., prob. (18)73], Member, 1879, Coatesville Class 1881,

Class 1882] Died 1891; one of the “spinster sisters”, with her older sister, Elizabeth. [Note 11].

[26] Phebe [Pike] McAninch, born 1827, in Ohio, daughter of Tristram and Margaret Pike, married

Daniel [not H.] McAninch, 7 Sept. 1843, in Hendricks County; Pleasant Hill, Member 1861, 1862,

Pleasant Hill Class [H.2., est. 1863], Coatesville, Member 1867, Coatesville Class 1870,

Coatesville? Class [H.5., prob. (18)73], Member, 1879, Coatesville Class 1881, Coatesville Class

1882. Wife of Daniel McA., Phebe (Pike) died 1883, and is buried in Stilesville Cemetery.

[27] Polly Margaret McAninch, daughter of Daniel H. and Phebe (Pike) McAninch, born about 1846;

Coatesville, Probationers, 1862, Single [age 15-16], Pleasant Hill Class [H.2., est. 1863] [Note 16].

[28] Rhoda W. (Wilson) McAninch, born 1848, wife of Daniel A. McAninch [see Note 9];

Coatesville, Member 1867, then “Joined Radical Methodist”, (and then later, they came back?).

Member, ca. 1906-1916, Member, est. 1917-1918. Rhoda died 1930, buried Coatesville cemetery.

[29] Sam’l [Samuel] McAninch, Amo, Member 1867, “Not member since 1873”. Probably Samuel,

son of John W. and Martha Ann (Smith) McA., born abt. 1851, age 19 in 1870 Census [Note 14].

Methodist Episcopal Church, Coatesville, Indiana	M E Coates .doc, page 6 of 7
McAninch Family History NL, VI-1 January, 1998 Copyright Frank McAninch page 1998-13